Comedy’s Kill Screen
By Kathryn Geurin
John Oliver
Colonial TheatRe, Pittsfield, Mass., Aug. 14
Chances are you know John Oliver as the Daily Show’s Senior British Correspondent. Perhaps you’ve heard that
“adorable accent” on his TimesOnline podcast, The Bugle, which recently celebrated its 100th episode. Maybe
you’ve seen his comedy special Terrifying
Times, or his six-episode John
Oliver's New York Stand Up Show, or any number of his other assorted
appearances on stage and screen. The guy’s only been in the U.S. for four
years, his green card is still sparkling—and already he’s rocketing up the
ladder to comedy stardom at surprising speeds for such a gangly chap.
So the question really isn’t “Was John Oliver funny?” Because,
yes. Yes, of course, he was funny. Brilliantly, preposterously funny. The kind
of funny that leaves you stretching the ache from your jaw the next morning.
The kind of funny that, between reminiscing laughs on the ride home, smacks you
with the fleeting fear: “What if I just experienced the funniest hour and a
half of my life? What if all humor is downhill from here?”
Yes. He was that kind of funny.
Oliver tumbled onto the stage already laughing, beaming under his
dark tousle of hair, an impishness brewing behind his wire-rimmed glasses. His “fake
news” correspondent’s suit was retired for the evening in favor of sneakers, slim
khakis and a plaid button-down.
“The Colonial Theater,” he snickered, surveying the golden
balconies of Pittsfield’s historic opera house, “the Colonial Theater. You have to understand what it does to a British
person walking into Massachusetts . . . such a defeat. I should be standing on
this stage in a delightful red jacket shooting a musket and shouting
instructions. Instead, you’ve called me here to dance for you like a jester.”
And so began the brief love affair between John Oliver and the Colonial
Theater audience—a dazzling tryst of the type most performers only dream. Oliver
deftly rolled between his intended material and comfortably hilarious, meandering
riffs born of his rare chemistry with an audience that he facetiously asked to
“laugh a bit less,” cursing their collective travel experience and swooning
over the hearty response he got to a Galileo joke. “Even your heckles are
good,” he smirked.
When he dropped to his knees, gasping, “What kind of Narnia have
I stumbled into?” the cynic in me flinched: You probably say that to all the
gigs.
And maybe he does, though
I thoroughly doubt it. But it’s really irrelevant. Because either way, he made
us laugh, and think, and love our madcap country anew. He convinced some
hundreds of folks in Pittsfield that each wingnut story he spun, each intimate
laugh and quirky observation was crafted in that moment, for that moment.
Oliver offers cultural commentary from an outsider, not in the
broad, tired strokes of partisan stereotype, but through the specifics, the
eccentric details “under the hood” of our nation, be it a 70-year-old tour
guide with a hockey-stick crutch and a self-set leg in upper Michigan, a Guiness
World Record set for most rattlesnakes held in one’s mouth (10), or the fact
that the Colonial Theater was for decades, ludicrously, a paint store. What
Oliver does best is hold a mirror to America, and the reflection he creates
echoes with surprisingly resonant mix of savvy criticism, insightful amusement
and genuine affection.
“Oh, Pittsfield,” he sighed, having run unexpectedly overtime, “I
will remember this gig much longer than you will.”
Doubtful, John Oliver. Doubtful.
Recent Comments